Trade Me buyer 'scammed by dead woman'

The watch auction that proved to be dodgy. SUPPLIED.

A man who says he was scammed by a fraudster impersonating a dead woman on Trade Me wants the site to give more information about how it happened.

Glenn Clark purchased a watch for $480 on the evening of December 28, from a Trade Me account that had 100 per cent positive feedback over 396 trades.

He says he received purchase confirmation from Trade Me and a “very plausible" email from the alleged seller.

He then received confirmation from Trade Me that a courier had been booked, so he paid the $480 by direct credit.

But the next morning, he received another email from Trade Me, this time telling him not to go through with the trade.

“The seller of this auction is not legitimate and has been removed from Trade Me,” it said. “The listing was created by a scammer, not a genuine Trade Me member. If you've paid any money to this person please contact your bank immediately.”

He contacted his bank, who told him that the number he had been given was an overseas money transfer service operated by ANZ.

“BNZ contacted ANZ to stop payment and I was fortunate the overseas transfer hadn’t been made and I recovered the money.”

An online search revealed that the alleged Trade Me seller, who had a relatively unusual name, had died in March 2022 in a Tauranga rest home.

“Trade Me refused to tell me how the scammer was able to access the deceased vendor’s account and run the scam, hiding behind the Privacy Act. I’ve written again without answer.”

Glenn says, as a result of the scam, the fraudster had his name, email and home address, as well as his phone number.

“It’s my privacy that’s been breached. I began receiving one of two phishing emails each day, blocked them and they’ve stopped.

“We're left in the dark as to how the scammer obtained the Trade Me account login credentials and how Trade Me was alerted to the scam. I'm grateful to Trade Me for alerting me so I didn't incur a financial loss but the loss of privacy and the inconvenience still annoys me. Why won't Trade Me tell me what happened?”

He says Trade Me gave him insufficient information about what happened.

Trade Me policy and compliance manager James Ryan says he could not comment on individual cases.

“Scammers are becoming more sophisticated and their methods more complex, which is why it’s never been more important to be vigilant and use trusted platforms,” he said.

“We have advanced systems and a dedicated NZ-based team to keep our site safe, and we're constantly looking at new ways we can protect our members. Sadly, however, there are some devious people online who will try to steal or scam people out of their money.”

He says members should use Ping or Afterpay because means the buyer protection policy applies and the payment can be tracked.

”If you get contacted by one of these scammers, or are suspicious that you might be dealing with one, contact our team and we’ll take a look”

1 comment

Don't expect an explanation; be glad you got your money back

Posted on 18-01-2024 17:08 | By morepork

TradeMe don't know how the login credentials were obtained and they behaved properly as soon as they became aware of the situation. The Banks also acted quickly and the victim got his money back. This is a case of identity theft with a scammer using a valid account. TradeMe were probably not told of the lady's demise and that is a vulnerability that ANY company can suffer from. There are a number of ways in which hackers can obtain login credentials, but you can't blame TradeMe (or any other Internet trader) for any of them. Personally, I shop on the internet frequently. BUT, I always establish the identity of ANYONE who I will be sending money to, and I NEVER allow any trader to save my credit card details. (Always use a Banking gateway). Internet trading is mostly safe, but the bad buggers are becoming increasingly sophisticated. Caveat Emptor!


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.