The Government's decision to switch taxi companies used to transport special-needs children to and from school has been labelled 'a shambles” and 'unprepared” by one Tauranga principal.
At the end of last year the Government decided to change taxi companies in Tauranga, central Auckland, the North Shore, Whangarei and South Auckland through a tender process.
Kaka Street Special School principal Barrie Wickens with Teacher Aid & Go Bus driver Glennis Bell and seven-year-old Areeb Umayr. Photo: Bruce Barnard.
Earlier this week, the Ministry of Education, who pay for taxis to and from school for some special-needs students, admitted up to 400 special-needs students have been placed at risk following the decision.
Kaka Street Special School principal Barrie Wickens says the school has been faced with ongoing concerns since the changeover in companies at the beginning of the school term, on February 4, which he says the school was not informed about.
'Have we got concerns? Yes, it has been a shambles since day one. Basically after 11 school days things are finally starting to settle down.
Barrie says the Government's decision meant Tauranga Mount Taxis lost the contract to an Auckland based company Alert Taxis, which has since sub-contracted the job to New Zealand Taxis.
'Alert Taxis were not prepared. There was no official information that they were awarded the contract and we have not received a list of the children they are transporting.”
Of the school's 63 special-needs students aged between five and 21-years-old, 10 are transported by the taxi company.
Barrie says since the changeover some children have not been picked up, and the company did not have enough vehicles to accommodate the school. He also says they have had reports of the children running from the taxi when they are picked up.
Barrie says the school did not receive any information regarding the changeover in companies, or about the exact level of understanding the drivers have for catering for special-needs children.
The student's being collected suffer from Cerebral Palsy, brain damage and Rett's Syndrome, while some also have communication or hearing disorders, visual impairments and intellectual disabilities.
Barrie has met twice with the company's Waikato/Bay of Plenty manager Andy Collins to sort out the problem, but admits he will continue to ask for regular meetings before reviewing the issue after six weeks.
'We will be working very closely with the families, the drivers and their managers because they have created a shambles to start with and have created many unknowns about what skills they have.”
New Zealand's leading disability services provider CCS Disability Action says the changeover of school transport providers has disadvantaged students with special needs.
CCS Disability Action chief executive David Matthews says he is aware of several problems with the changes across the country and the process has been unacceptable.
'Students may have missed out on school and been transported unsafely because of recent changes in providers.
'This is quite frankly unacceptable. This process should have been a positive one where the Ministry ensured that all new providers are using fully accessible vehicles to provide for current and future need.
'Whatever is going on behind the scenes needs to be managed. Students should not be disadvantaged by a change of providers. At the end of the day, the focus should be on the student. It is simply not acceptable for any students to miss out on school or have their access to school compromised.”
David hoped the Ministry of Education and transport providers had learnt from the experience.
'In many cases, existing providers and drivers had good relationships with students and their families. This should have been taken into account in the re-tendering process.
'The Government also needs to learn that when tendering, there are often wider costs and challenges which they need to take into account.”
Waikato/Bay of Plenty manager Andy was unable to be reached for comment by SunLive today.



9 comments
Unfair to blame Govt for trying to get better price
Posted on 27-02-2013 13:00 | By Phailed
Of course its unfortunate there have been problems, but what about the alternative? The alternative is to virtually give someone a contract for life at some sort of sky's the limit rate. Has anyone caught a taxi lately? Do you realise the extremely high price of taxis in Tauranga? Some people seem to think money grows on trees.
Ex-teacher
Posted on 27-02-2013 14:03 | By jeancraven@kinect.co.nz
Decisions are being made by paper shufflers and not those involved in the care and learning of students with disabilities - not good enough.
take control of our own needs
Posted on 27-02-2013 16:17 | By traceybjammet
I dont know why the school doesnt get its own special mini-van and get a driver and even if a gold-coin donation for a weekly pickup is contributed etc. fundraising and grants together would mean the school and parents have more control over their kids needs taxis are hardly reliable at the best of times
Disgrace
Posted on 27-02-2013 18:56 | By Elba
Its just another Goverment cut back to save costs those people responsible for the changes are just ripping off the vunerable anyone who rips off people who have a disability by taking away what they are used to is a Disgrace, i hope this is sorted soon those poor kids
DUE DILIGENCE???
Posted on 27-02-2013 19:07 | By waiknot
Well if you give a company with only 1/2 a dozen or so Taxis a contract for about a dozen or more school runs clearly they are not in a position to fulfill the contract, Alert Taxis (Taxi Cabs in Tauranga)are lucky that New Zealand Cabs came to their assistance otherwise there would have been absolute chaos.
disability transport
Posted on 27-02-2013 20:26 | By rosscoo
should not make any difference who has contract if school provides details of people to be collected then know problem obliviously this principal looking for problems that are not there instead of working to help make a better service.
Deja Vu
Posted on 27-02-2013 21:09 | By YadaYada
Same thing happened 7 years ago when Go Bus took the runs over. No body complains about them now.
Same moaning whenever someone loses their nice contract
Posted on 28-02-2013 09:52 | By Phailed
It seems to have become a habit. Whenever competition is introduced to keep prices more manageable there are the usual cries from those I guess to whom money is no object. As far I can see this Govt is borrowing $350 million every week. But their cost efficiency drive should focus on plenty of other things as well, including MPs and bureaucrats expenses and salaries.
Parent of one of these children
Posted on 17-03-2013 21:45 | By silverhorn
It has been nothing but extra stress and chaos since it began. These people picking up our children are NOT used to dealing with children with special needs. They have no clue how to handle half of the social issues our children face let alone make them feel comfortable. They have no skills when it comes to dealing with us parents let alone our children. It wasn't until we got a regular driver (which has lasted about 2 weeks) that we actually started to get less issues about going to school. Its not easy for us parents of these children who have so much more issues we have to deal with to have to deal with the government suddenly thinking they know what is best for our children. This government has shown on many occasions that special needs children are irrelevant as far as they are concerned, this is just one more way they are showing us. Don't judge us parents for complaining and wanting what is best for our children. We don't judge you and you have no clue what it means to be us!
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to make a comment.