Council adopts flawed study

Tauranga City councillors adopted a new roading strategy for the city this week, in spite of being told sections of the strategy may require a major re-think.

Photo: file.

The Tauranga Transport Strategy 2012-2042 uses Smartgrowth's population growth predictions to plan the city's roading requirements during the next 30 years.

The study analyses expected industrial and commercial growth areas and provides guidelines for the roading requirements to keep the city moving.

But a fundamental assumption behind the strategy is being called into question by the New Zealand Transport Agency, which is signalling the city may no longer count on being able to use the state highways for cross-town traffic, and parallel links may have to be constructed.

When city councillors adopted the new roading strategy in this week's TCC City Vision meeting, Tauranga City Mayor Stuart Crosby confirmed NZTA's stance, saying: 'It's a relatively new direction from NZTA”.

But TCC city infrastructure planning team leader Philip King says NZTA 'are becoming more and more vocal”.

'It's all contained in a new process the NZTA is developing called the One Network Road Classification.

'It contains classifications for every road in the country, not just the NZTA's state highway networks, but city networks as well, and classifying the networks on national, regional and local outcomes.

'What they [NZTA] are saying is that where corridors have a national focus, they want to see less local traffic on them,” says Philip, who spoke to SunLive after the meeting.

An example of the policy is the NZTA footing the $50 million bill for the Welcome Bay underpass, because it removes local traffic from the state highway.

'That's an example of it happening. The consequence of that on the existing network is something I'm not fully sure about. I think it's more likely to be a conversation with new areas,” says Philip.

'Because SH29, between Tauriko and Te Maunga, is the only arterial road there is absolutely no real choice at the moment – and that isn't a situation that will be resolved by us building a new road tomorrow.

'It's something that will happen as the city grows over 30-40 years, rather than immediately.”

It may in future be a factor in the timing of the SH2 northern arterial, as this link would take traffic away from the Bethlehem Town Centre, says Philip.

'On the other side of town if the Granada St and Gloucester Rd street links were connected, they'd also take a lot of traffic off the state highway.”

But completing this road-link is at the whim of developers, rather than council, says Philip.

'It's just an example of a case where a lack of local connections is putting more pressure on the highway network.”

The updated roading strategy has taken about two years to prepare, with changes in NZTA's stance being more recent.

'It's something that's been coming out over the last 12 months and it's still not fully finished, but it's just a new process that we need to align with,” says Philip.

'Certainly, during the last 12 months, the strategy has changed to reflect the new processes that are coming out.

'It's part of the reason for the delay. But it is a 30-year document and we have opportunities to review it in three years, six years.”

12 comments

no surpises there

Posted on 04-05-2014 15:56 | By Astoreth

TCC built Route K on flawed growth predictions, so it should come as no surprise that they are continuing the trend.


Nothing new Mr Mayor ...

Posted on 04-05-2014 18:32 | By Murray.Guy

Tauranga City Mayor Stuart Crosby confirmed NZTA's stance, saying: 'It's a relatively new direction from NZTA”. ... Come on Mayor Crosby, we've known of this for years. Another reason why the 'deal you've struck' with the NZTA is not good for our community. We get to retain the debt and loose control and associated network benefits! Another reason why the Prime Minister through the NZTA need to be reminded of their 'promise' to upgrade the central corridor (15th Avenue, Turret Rd)before it's highway status is revoked ratepayers get lumbered with it!


WHAT

Posted on 04-05-2014 18:39 | By FunandGames

To quote "An example of the policy is the NZTA footing the $50 million bill for the Welcome Bay underpass, because it removes local traffic from the state highway." I thought they are paying for it becouse it was an election bribe, ops sorry promice.


Fairly ordinary

Posted on 04-05-2014 21:47 | By Chris

Our councillors aren't known to be influenced by mere facts. This shouldn't present a problem.


And...

Posted on 05-05-2014 08:21 | By penguin

...let's not forget the southern pipeline!!


huh

Posted on 05-05-2014 10:33 | By Capt_Kaveman

i told them this some 20yrs ago eg look at Hewletts rd, Cameron rd is a disaster mainly cose of a failed expressway construction, now Totara st is now governed by the odd cross traffic causing chaos, reason lack of planning and easy stamped sub dividers & biz useless layouts


$100 million

Posted on 05-05-2014 11:43 | By Colleen Spiro

The original promise made by the Govt was 100 million to do the WHOLE project including the tunnel AND Turret Rd, but part of that was traded off 4 the 2nd harbour bridge, way before the 100 million announcement


$100 million

Posted on 05-05-2014 12:29 | By Colleen Spiro

Everyone seems to have forgotten that the original amount promised by the Government was $100 million to complete both the tunnel AND the two laning of Turret Road......where did the the other $50 million go....I believe it went long before the promise as a trade-off for the 2nd harbour bridge. So sadly we will not get the works that were originally promised.....no surprised there.


Small BUT critical correction Kiaora2u

Posted on 05-05-2014 14:42 | By Murray.Guy

The promise that is now an 'overdue debt' was to complete the upgrade from Cameron Rd, to include 4-lanes including Hairini Bridge and underpass. The estimate cost to the Government was put at $100m. This is important to understand as the Mayor, TCC Staff and NZTA will attempt to say the debt is being met with $50m on the under[pass and a future $50m subsidy with $50m rates to complete the works. They will also attempt to include the costs of the traffic lights. The media release from John Key can be found here: https://www.national.org.nz/news/news/media-releases/detail/2008/11/03/key-green-lights-tauranga-central-corridor


Smartgrowth

Posted on 05-05-2014 18:16 | By YOGI BEAR

Population projections, yes they are flawed, everyone knows that but that keep on justifying themselves by making the projection angle steeper to keep on getting the same answers. Result spending up large on infrastructure that will be warn out before needed.


Murray

Posted on 06-05-2014 09:11 | By YOGI BEAR

Perhaps it is summarized as: - "More debt and no toll income". Not a good look as all just went from bad to worse ...


Agree Murray

Posted on 06-05-2014 09:21 | By YOGI BEAR

Yes it is messy to say the least, the link says it all so having read that, how possibly could TCC ratepayers benefit from the deal done over Route K and Turret Road? Looks to me that all has just gone from bad to worse really fast?


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.