Chosen trees anger resident

A Katikati resident is dismayed with Tauranga City Council's decision to replace felled trees in the city centre with another large species.

John Deans says the Council's decision to replace felled Illawarra flame trees on Grey Street with katsura trees makes no sense as they will grow to be bigger than the predecessors.


A felled Illawarra flame tree on Grey Street.

Council began removing the Illawarra trees last week after the roots started blowing out cobbles on the road and there were issues with birds roosting in the trees.

A Tauranga City Council communications advisor Marcel Currin says three high priority trees have been removed, including two trees near the intersection with Elizabeth Street.

Work to remove two more trees is expected to begin today.

He says the felled trees are being replaced with palms and katsura trees as they are less desirable for birds to nest in. Tree pits will also be built to protect the infrastructure.

But 74-year-old John Deans says council has made the wrong decision choosing katsura trees as they can grow to larger than 55feet in circumference and 30metres tall.

'Another problem is they don't seem to be particularly suited to this environment,” says John.

'It would be a lovely tree at McLaren Falls Park where it has room to grow – it's not the sort of thing you put in the street.

'It's just so sad to plant the wrong trees in the city for the wrong reasons.”

John, who is a tree enthusiast and past council consultant for parks and reserves, says if the council are trying to curb the bird populations, changing the tree type will not help.

He says the birds' food sources need to be controlled or the problem will not stop.

'If people continue to feed the sparrows in any form they will continue to live there.”

John wants to see citizen input as to what should be planted.

'There are some very qualified people within the district who could make good suggestions.

'You really want a tree that's not going to outgrow the size of the area in which it's planted.”

4 comments

JOHN IS RIGHT

Posted on 07-09-2012 09:27 | By TERMITE

The Katsura trees will be larger, so have a bigger effect on the paving in time and provide even more places for birds than now. That will take a few years but the the end result is worse than the current problem, looks like someone wants to make a bigger mess than now, like road contractors, infrastructure contractors and tree huggers.


since

Posted on 07-09-2012 09:43 | By Capt_Kaveman

when have this council had any brains, trees roads an buildings do not mix


Thought for the future...?

Posted on 07-09-2012 12:30 | By penguin

...and this council and "advisors" won't be around to accept any responsibility! To support critics, here are the statistics for the tree from a big tree grower's web site) - The Katsura tree grows to a height of 40 to 60 feet (12-18m) and has a spread of 30 to 50 feet (9-15m) when it is fully matured. It is considered a medium-sized tree and has a growth rate of 12 to 18 inches (.5m) a year. You can likely double the growth rate (and final size) for Tauranga!!!


trees

Posted on 08-09-2012 15:45 | By sangrae

I agree with john does the council arborist really know what he is talking about, maybe a group of like minded people should be consulted


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.