Ban phones in classroom, not in breaks - survey

Many schools already ban mobile phone use in lessons.

Most New Zealanders support cellphones being banned in the classroom, but not at break times.

The National-led government says it will ban mobiles in schools altogether.

Students will have to drop off their phones at the start of the day and collect them at home time.

Horizon Research polled four possible policy options:

  • 61 per cent supported banning mobile phone use at all schools during class time, but not during breaks
  • 56 per cent supported a ban on use for the whole school day
  • 16 per cent said there should be no ban (60 percent disagreed with that view)
  • 52 per cent supported letting schools decide

Horizon's survey of 1481 adults also found that a ban during class, but not during breaks, is the most favoured option among those with children in their households - 63 per cent supported this.

Only 22 per cent of people with children thought there should be no ban at all.

Support for a ban, but not during class breaks, was highest in Northland, where 79 per cent supported that option.

Horizon said that although the phone ban policy was reported as being controversial during the election campaign, it had solid public support. Tweaking the policy to allow mobile use during class breaks would maximise support.

The survey was conducted November 10-16 . Respondents represent the New Zealand adult population. At a 95 per cent confidence level, the maximum margin of error is +/- 2.5 per cent.

-RNZ.

6 comments

Phone ban

Posted on 29-11-2023 22:11 | By Sycamore2

Students don't need phones during their breaks, they should spend the time conversing face to face with each other.


BAN PHONES BETWEEN 9 AND 3

Posted on 29-11-2023 22:44 | By Bruja

ALL of the school day. Kids in 'break' times should be interacting with each other, socialising, NOT on cellphones.
The End.


It's easy...

Posted on 30-11-2023 12:36 | By morepork

... to say: "Ban phones". But the real objective is to NOT let phones be a distraction during lessons. You do that by banning their use during lessons and confiscating them if that breach is banned. The phone is retrieved on payment of a small fine, which can be paid any time after the end of school on that day. Kids have been given a right to have phones and whether you like it or not and whether you approve of the death of conversation has nothing to do with that. Banning phones will NOT raise education standards; that requires better class sizes and more teachers.


The Master

Posted on 30-11-2023 12:37 | By Ian Stevenson

They are an addiction, not a necessity, many very much confuse these two things. The former is the fact of it, the latter NO WAY.

Kids need people skills more than ever, the internet fails at all levels. Get rid of the mobiles, at most they are some use for calls etc but that is about it. No wonder the planet is embarking on a zombie, brain dead generation or to coming through.


Excellent News For All

Posted on 01-12-2023 07:27 | By Thats Nice

I have spoken to teachers about the use of cellphones at school and it is a huge problem, so this is great news. Kids think they are entitled to have their phones in the classroom and when asked to put them away in many cases get abused for doing so. Now the curriculum needs overhauling so our children are learning the things that will help them for their futures instead of a lot of rubbish currently being taught.


@Thats Nice

Posted on 01-12-2023 12:12 | By morepork

Thanks for reporting what teachers said. Their opinion should have more weight in this discussion. If you give someone a cell phone they will feel entitled to carry it and use it. It has to be clear that the classroom is not a place where use of the phone is acceptable. I may be out of touch with classroom discipline as it is many years since I was teaching, but I never had problems with discipline when I did. (I'm pleased to say I never caned or strapped anybody during the short time I was teaching; but I did sometimes remove privileges (always temporarily). If we have reached a pass now where the teacher has no authority, then it is hardly surprising that learning is not happening. Without discipline, there can be no learning, whether they have cell phones or not.


Leave a Comment


You must be logged in to make a comment.